Review of The Valley of Horses, the second book in the epic Earth’s Children series by Jean M. Auel of historical fiction set in prehistoric Europe.
This post may contain affiliate links, which means I may receive a commission, at no extra cost to you, if you make a purchase through a link. Please see our full disclosure for further information.
Synopsis
After leaving the group of Neanderthals that raised her, Ayla is unable to find other humans, and settles in a protected valley. She initially plans to stay for the winter but ends up remaining there for three years. During that time, she adopts a foal and raises a baby cave lion.
While Ayla’s in the valley, two brothers journey eastward along the river later called the Danube. They meet many people during their travels, and spend some time living with a group called the Sharamudoi. After the death of the woman he loves, the younger brother, Thonolan, loses his will to live.
Ayla finds the two young men after they have been mauled by her lion. Thonolan is dead, but she takes the other brother, Jondalar, back to her cave and saves his life. From Jondalar, Ayla learns about her own kind of people and the two of them form a relationship.
Review
I liked The Valley of Horses at the beginning, and it got better at the end. I’ve read and re-read the good parts over and over again.
In the first part of the book, I preferred the Ayla parts of the story to the Jondalar parts, but the Jondalar parts are necessary for the pace of the story and for action. Also, without the Jondalar parts, I wouldn’t have had the background that I needed to appreciate the rest of the story.
I loved seeing Ayla develop into her own person after being held back trying to fit in with the Clan. When she was living with the clan, a lot of her personality showed that she was different from everyone else. She had to suppress her smiles and laughter in order to fit in and survive. Living on her own, she could be curious, express her creativity, and follow her own inclinations as much as she liked.
‘She was thinking about naming the horse. I’ve never named anything before, she smiled to herself. Wouldn’t they think I was strange, naming a horse? Not any stranger than living with one. She watched the young animal racing and frisking playfully. I’m so glad she lives with me, Ayla thought, feeling a lump in her throat. It’s not so lonely with her around. I don’t know what I would do if I lost her now.‘
I found the number of innovations that Ayla came up with unrealistic for one person. She domesticates horses, makes fire with stones, and invents the travois to help her carry the animals she hunts. Individually, the circumstances surrounding each invention and discovery are reasonable, however put all together it is just too much for one person to have done.
Jondalar is too perfect; he’s tall, handsome, sensitive, intelligent, and everyone loves him. I usually don’t like characters like that, preferring characters to have a flaw or two and be more relatable. However, Jondalar’s perfection is recognised and we are shown some of the problems that it brings him. This made him much more likeable.
Conclusion
Have you read The Valley of Horses? What did you think? Do you agree with what I’ve said about it? Let me know in the comments.
