Posted on Leave a comment

Review: The Queen’s Musician by Martha Jean Johnson

front cover of The Queen's Musician by Martha Jean Johnson

Book Review of The Queen’s Musician by Martha Jean Johnson, an historical fiction novel set during the time of Henry VIII and Anne Boleyn, due to be released 27th May 2025.

Front cover of The Queen's Musician by Martha Jean Johnson
Save Me to Pinterest !!!

Synopsis

When Cardinal Wolsey gifts Hampton Court to King Henry VIII, Mark Smeaton becomes a court musician. While it takes him some time to prove himself to the new senior musicians, he eventually becomes one of Anne Boleyn’s favourites, frequently being asked to provide entertainment for her and her attendants. 

During the king and Lady Anne’s first stay at Hampton Court, Mark meets her cousin, Madge Shelton. Though instantly attracted to each other, Mark and Madge cannot even speak. Even looking at each other for too long could jeopardise Madge’s chances of a profitable marriage. 

Through Mark and Madge’s eyes, we see the king and queen become increasingly unhappy with each other. But they have other things to focus on. Mark manages to make enough money to buy two horses, and Madge’s mother arranges a suitable marriage for her. Until one day, Mark is arrested, accused of adultery and treason. 

Review

The story of Henry VIII and Anne Boleyn has almost been done to death. There are already thousands of books on the subject. I liked how this book took the familiar story and told it from a completely different (largely unknown) point of view.

The Queen’s Musician gets off to a bit of a slow start. It feels like there is a lot of backstory and establishing who everyone is. However, I don’t think it has more set-up than other books – it just felt like it because the main characters spend most of the book going about their normal lives with no obvious movement towards the ending.

I think this also helps to show the shock and surprise Mark must have felt at being accused of treason. He does notice that Queen Anne was getting more irritable, and that she’s arguing with the king more. But he doesn’t consider that King Henry might try to get rid of her, or that he might get caught up in it. One day Mark’s making music, with no idea of what’s going on, and the next he’s being accused of adultery with the Queen. 

Despite the difficult ending, The Queen’s Musician was a light read. It wasn’t overwhelmed with details, and kept out a lot of the fear and other emotions you’d expect. Instead of dwelling on Mark and Madge’s anger, fear, and sadness over his eventual execution, it focuses on them overcoming the situation and making the most of what they’ve got. That being said, I did cry my way through the last three or four chapters.

Conclusion

The Queen’s Musician by Martha Jean Johnson is due to be released on 27th May 2025.

Posted on 2 Comments

Review: The Other Boleyn Girl by Philippa Gregory

Book review of The Other Boleyn Girl, an historical fiction novel set in Tudor England by Philippa Gregory.

The Other Boleyn Girl by Philippa Gregory cover
Save Me on Pinterest !!

This post may contain affiliate links, which means I may receive a commission, at no extra cost to you, if you make a purchase through a link. Please see our full disclosure for further information.

Synopsis

This book follows Mary, sister of Anne Boleyn (Henry VIII’s second wife). Mary is lady-in-waiting to Queen Katherine of Aragon when she catches the king’s eye. Her ambitious and overbearing uncle sees an opportunity and quickly removes Mary from her husband’s household. Before long, she is in the king’s bed advancing her family’s fortunes.

After she has borne him a daughter and a son, Henry’s attentions stray to Mary’s beautiful older sister, and Mary is ordered to help Anne catch the king. As always, she obeys, but then Anne falls out of favour and their entire family is put at risk.

Review

Like Philippa Gregory’s other Plantagenet/Tudor books, The Other Boleyn Girl is heavy reading with many historical tidbits. Generally, I find that Philippa Gregory sticks to the historical record, but also goes along with whatever current theories happen to be popular. When reading this book, you do have to keep in mind that it is a novel, and as such is not historically perfect.

I loved the relationship between Mary and William Stafford. William was obviously able to give her the kind of life she wanted but couldn’t have being at court all the time. I really admire Mary’s strength in standing up to her uncle and leaving her family with William. I’ve come across Thomas Howard before and he was clearly a Horrible Man.

“Who d’you think is hearing the evidence against these men? Who will be president of the court against your brother? Your own uncle! Does he use his influence to save him? Does your father? No.”

Most of The Other Boleyn Girl is written from Mary’s POV. This makes some of the characters seem one-sided. For example, Catherine of Aragon is portrayed as an older woman/role-model who can do nothing bad.

The exception to this is Mary’s brother and sister. Mary has a real love/hate relationship with George and Anne. She loves them both dearly, but is often jealous of or frustrated at them. Like when Anne denies Mary permission to see her children, Mary hates Anne.

That being said, this book didn’t push sympathy for Anne Boleyn under the reader’s nose. Many people see Anne as a victim, and she is usually portrayed as one. The Other Boleyn Girl shows her doing some questionable things but also as a victim who had few choices and did what she was pushed to.

Conclusion

Have you read The Other Boleyn Girl? What did you think? Do you agree with what I’ve said about it? Let me know in the comments.